Keeping a company health scheme affordable when claims soared
At First Health, we work with companies from two employees to hundreds. This case study shows how we took on a firm of London surveyors just three weeks before their renewal. We brought a steep premium increase down and kept their staff well looked after.
![1[1]](https://www.firsthealthpmi.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/11-1.png)
Who is the client?
First Health was recommended to a firm of surveyors based in central London by a Mortgage & Protection adviser, who is also a client of ours. She liked the creative way we had dealt with her other clients and her own company scheme and told us how impressed she was with our knowledge and expertise. Her preference was to recommend specialists, as all we do day in, day out is medical insurance and wellbeing programmes. In our industry, someone who recommends us like this is called an introducer.
The surveyors’ company health insurance scheme was with Aviva. It covered 27 employees plus partners and dependents. It was three weeks before their renewal on 1st October 2026, and they had not yet had any word from their current broker. The same thing had happened the year before, and they no longer had a personal relationship with a specific person at their broker. They told us they felt like a very small cog in a big wheel and wanted to be looked after, and looked after well.
Premiums were increasing, and a whole of market review (a comparison of policies from across all the main insurers) from their national broker was expected. Their annual premiums were due to rise from £42,404 to £61,447, because of a range of claims throughout the year. The scheme was running at a loss ratio of 200%. This meant the insurer had paid out twice as much in claims as it received in premiums, and high claims had been made for a number of years.
What did we do?
In almost all instances, we contact our business clients 8-12 weeks before the renewal. We want to know if there have been any significant changes, to speak to the person in the company responsible for looking after the scheme, and to find out about any serious claims. The insurers typically send us the renewal information around 8 weeks before renewal. That leaves enough time to review the scheme, assess whether the benefits need amending and carry out a full market review. If keeping costs down is crucial to the company, we also build a cost containment strategy, a plan to hold premiums down.
It’s important to note that we don’t charge fees, as we receive commission from the insurers, so there is no additional outlay for the client. Our aim is to build strong relationships with our clients, enjoy what we do and do a great job at the same time.
We insist on being the appointed broker, which means the client formally authorises us to deal with their insurer on their behalf, so that we can be in complete control. Without that commitment from our client, we cannot provide the level of service we strive to give, and we will not take it on. It’s not just about getting some quotes and hoping for the best. In a lot of cases, clients don’t want to switch to another insurer. They want to stay with their current insurer, which is why we need to be their broker. A lot of clients think all we want to do is switch the scheme, and that’s not the case at all.
The surveyors were impressed with our track record and really respected the lady who recommended us. As time was short, they signed the appointment forms; we gathered as much information as possible, and we started working on the renewal. It was fairly intense due to the limited time available. We reminded the clients about their current benefits, explained what was possible and agreed on a strategy we felt could bring the premiums down. We also planned to alter some of the benefits, as their needs had changed since the scheme was originally set up. Our clients felt there was no hope, but we encouraged them to have faith in us, as we had a plan. They said that for the first time in years they felt they were in safe hands.
What was the solution?
Following our review of the market, the other main insurers (Bupa, AXA, Vitality, PHC and Freedom Health) did not offer particularly good terms, as they felt the risk was too high. We spoke to Aviva, who were extremely helpful. We changed some of the benefits, created new categories of cover to dig deep into what the members needed, and removed the benefits that weren’t required. The outcome brought the annual premiums down from £61,447 to £52,806, a healthy saving under the circumstances.
We also introduced a couple of other schemes. One could help pay towards the £200 excess, the amount each person pays towards a claim. The other diverted some of the therapy claims away from Aviva to a scheme that offered excellent value for money to the employees, partners and dependents.
We advised that we would administer the leavers and joiners (the staff leaving and joining the scheme) throughout the year. We also provided our service charter, which simply offers a very responsive service if we are needed. The service charter is also given to the introducer, so that they understand how we operate and how we keep them updated about their clients. We aim to offer the best service possible, as we appreciate our introducers need to trust that we will handle their clients with the same care and attention they give them.
What would normally have taken us 4-6 weeks, we completed in 10 days, as it was all hands to the pump. The partners at the surveying company were really impressed and grateful for what we had achieved for them. The client who referred us was also happy that we did a great job.
We did not finish there. Because the company was located relatively close to us and there were several benefit changes, we visited their offices. We presented the scheme to employees in person, answered their questions, clarified how to claim and educated them on when not to claim. We received really positive feedback, as the employees felt looked after by their company and really appreciated the advice. For companies located a longer distance away, we offer online presentations too.
Our hope is that the strategies in this case study demonstrate how every client is important to us. We work with companies from 2 employees to 100+, and these strategies will bode well for years to come. They keep costs at bay while maintaining strong wellbeing programmes that benefit everybody concerned.
Another happy client, happy introducer and another great relationship to build upon.
Questions this case study answers
Why has our company health insurance renewal gone up?
The main driver is usually your scheme’s own claims history. Other factors include rising medical costs and changes in the number and age of the people covered. Insurers often look at the loss ratio, which compares the claims they’ve paid with the premiums they’ve received. A high loss ratio usually means a larger increase.
In the case study above, a London surveying firm’s annual premium was due to rise from £42,404 to £61,447 after several years of high claims.
What is a loss ratio in company health insurance?
A loss ratio is the claims an insurer has paid out divided by the premiums it has received, shown as a percentage. At 100% the insurer has paid out exactly what it took in. Above 100%, it has paid out more than it received, which usually leads to a higher renewal price.
The scheme in the case study above had a loss ratio of 200%, meaning the insurer had paid out twice as much in claims as it received in premiums.
What can a company do when its health insurance renewal goes up sharply?
Start by asking for the renewal information early and reviewing the benefits. You can remove benefits that aren’t being used, restructure the cover or adjust the excess, and then compare the market and negotiate with your current insurer. Some companies also add separate plans, such as one that helps with the excess or covers everyday therapies, to take pressure off the main scheme.
See how we brought the surveying firm’s premium down from £61,447 to £52,806 in the case study above.
Do you have to switch insurer to reduce your company health insurance costs?
No. Often the cost can be brought down by restructuring the scheme with your current insurer. Switching isn’t always the best option, particularly if your scheme has a high claims history, because other insurers may price the risk even higher or treat ongoing conditions differently.
In the case study above, the firm stayed with Aviva, and we reduced the cost by changing the benefits.
When should a business start reviewing its health insurance renewal?
Ideally 8-12 weeks before the renewal date. Insurers typically send renewal terms around 8 weeks beforehand, which leaves time to review benefits, compare the market and negotiate.
The surveying firm in the case study above came to us just three weeks before renewal, and we still delivered a result in time.
How long does a company health insurance renewal review take?
A full review normally takes around 4-6 weeks. It can be done faster if time is short, but that leaves less room to compare options and negotiate.
We completed the review in the case study above in 10 days.
What does it mean to appoint a broker for your company health insurance?
You formally authorise the broker to deal with your insurer on your behalf. Insurers usually won’t discuss a scheme with an unauthorised third party, so without it a broker can’t get information, negotiate or administer the scheme properly. It also doesn’t mean you have to switch insurer. A broker can work with your existing one.
The surveying firm in the case study above signed the appointment forms so we could start straight away.
Can company health insurance help with the excess and therapy claims?
Yes, in some cases. Separate plans can help pay towards the excess, and some can take a share of therapy claims, such as physiotherapy, away from the main scheme. The right set-up depends on what your employees actually use.
In the case study above, we introduced one plan to help with the £200 excess and another to divert some therapy claims away from the main insurer.
Who manages leavers and joiners on a company health scheme?
Either the employer or the broker can. Many brokers, including First Health, administer leavers and joiners throughout the year on the company’s behalf.
We do this for the surveying firm in the case study above, alongside our service charter.
Should employers explain the health scheme to their staff?
It helps. When employees understand what’s covered, how to claim and when not to, they’re more likely to use the scheme well. Some brokers offer in-person or online presentations to staff, and First Health does both.
In the case study above, we visited the surveying firm’s offices to present the changes to employees, and the feedback was very positive.
How many employees do you need for a company health scheme?
Many insurers cover small groups, in some cases from as few as two employees. First Health works with companies from 2 employees to 100+.
